Monday November 23 2009

GotFrag Hardware Forums

Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 Gaming

1
31% Ranking 31% Ranking 31% Ranking 31% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

http://www.extremetech.com/article2/0,284..

Right now, Vista SP1 is still said to transfer files and run apps slower, but gaming differences are negligible with Vista SP1 actually being slightly faster now. What are your guys take on this? Is it worthwhile to switch to Vista SP1 or would you still wait for drivers to mature even more?
Compal JFL92 | Intel C2D t8300 | m8600GT 512MB DDR2 | Hitachi 200GB HDD | Windows XP SP3
2
22% Ranking 22% Ranking 22% Ranking 22% Ranking
-2 Frags
+   -

XP > VISTASUCKS
,,i,, ^_^ ,,i,,
3
8% Ranking 8% Ranking 8% Ranking 8% Ranking
-2 Frags
+   -

xp > vista
"I wont vote for Obama, because He's BL4CK" -eM-
5
6% Ranking 6% Ranking 6% Ranking 6% Ranking
-1 Frags
+   -

#1 Install both, see which you like the most (in speed ofc ;) )
6
3% Ranking 3% Ranking 3% Ranking 3% Ranking
-2 Frags
+   -

Vista pretty good.. No probs until now. use da mac theme for vista.

http://fc05.deviantart.com/fs30/f/2008/06..


Note: u wil need a third party "msstyle" applier

http://ftp.crystalxp.net/crystalxp.net/43..

This comment was edited at 08/03/2008 5:18 AM
MidNight Crew
8
9% Ranking 9% Ranking 9% Ranking 9% Ranking
+1 Frags
+   -

Doesn't matter benchmarks are very close. If you have XP I wouldn't buy Vista and just wait for some better technology to come out thats worth droping the coin on. If on the other hand you wanting to run 4gb of ram or above I would suggest Vista64 because its better than the XP flavor.

I'm running XP Sp3 right now with a custom build I made with http://www.nliteos.com/
Most the services turned off and other Microsoft crap they throw in for casuals
Runs great I like it better than Vista. I tried vista it wasn't a bad experience but not mind blowing enough to make me want to stay.

Till I have something I really want to play with DX10 turned on I'll stick with XP. Sorry to say but I Think game consoles are lagging this transition because of the older dx9 hardware most developers aren't wanting to jump on dx10 yet because it would just cost more money to develop for both. Hopefully we will have DX11 out before the next consoles are released so we can just skip DX10 altogether and won't have the lag issues on games as we are now.

This comment was edited at 08/03/2008 6:09 AM
9
30% Ranking 30% Ranking 30% Ranking 30% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

vista 64>
.Montreal.
10
124% Ranking 124% Ranking 124% Ranking 124% Ranking
-2 Frags
+   -

Windows 7 will drop in 1-2 years anyways; stick with XP.
11
19% Ranking 19% Ranking 19% Ranking 19% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Windows 7 = Vista SE
H4tw
12
10% Ranking 10% Ranking 10% Ranking 10% Ranking
-3 Frags
+   -

XP SP1 ftw
13
37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

#8 which no developers are actually going to use DX10 to its fullest since DX11 is just around the corner(sooner than we think).
14
11% Ranking 11% Ranking 11% Ranking 11% Ranking
+5 Frags
+   -

#13, dont upgrade to dx11 when it comes out because dx12 will be so much better, and it cant be too far away!
#cs-purgatory
15
53% Ranking 53% Ranking 53% Ranking 53% Ranking
+1 Frags
+   -

#14, don't upgrade to dx12 when it comes out because dx13 will be so much better, and it cant be too far away!
http://karacry.ytmnd.com/ I just wanna run KARA!!
16
63% Ranking 63% Ranking 63% Ranking 63% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

#15, don't upgrade to dx13 when it comes out because dx14 will be so much better, and it cant be too far away!
we have to go back
17
43% Ranking 43% Ranking 43% Ranking 43% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

after using XP Pro for years, and switching back and forth btwn. Vista and XP lately, Vista is finally kicking off and I'm starting to enjoy it :-D My opinion however :-X

and #8 don't blame consoles for delaying DX22 and the GeForce 5500029GTXGSOCSUPERCLOCKED, consoles are the butter to your bread.

This comment was edited at 08/03/2008 6:30 PM
MLG GoW2 Coverage -- UFragTV.com Administrator
18
10% Ranking 10% Ranking 10% Ranking 10% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Btw Windows 2000 is a real kickass for gaming. Tried it a while back. :)
19
37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

further solidifying my hatred for these forums.

anyways:
http://www.fpslabs.com/blogs/newbies-guid..
20
52% Ranking 52% Ranking 52% Ranking 52% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

which versions allow the use of more than 3.5GB of RAM ?
because i am about to buy that new PC with 8gb of ram...

isn't XPSP3 suppose to fix the block?
or will i have to go 64bits ?
21
124% Ranking 124% Ranking 124% Ranking 124% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

64-bit.
22
37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

div get to reading.
23
5% Ranking 5% Ranking 5% Ranking 5% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

He has spoken! Write down his words and call it the bible!
24
15% Ranking 15% Ranking 15% Ranking 15% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

vista > xp
25
4% Ranking 4% Ranking 4% Ranking 4% Ranking
-1 Frags
+   -

XP>ALL
26
37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

yes #23, i laughed so hard and even posted it as the topic in our irc chan. well the dailytech story about it.
27
1% Ranking 1% Ranking 1% Ranking 1% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

lol i agree to juanieh.

XP all the way.
28
41% Ranking 41% Ranking 41% Ranking 41% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

i just switched to vista 64 after years of xp, no reason not to use it, not sure why i waited!
gotfrag makes my trigger finger itchy!
29
113% Ranking 113% Ranking 113% Ranking 113% Ranking
-1 Frags
+   -

Vista is better than XP

Most people simply saying "XP > Vista" most likely have never tried Vista.

This comment was edited at 08/20/2008 7:04 AM
:)
30
13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Depends solely on what you want from your operating system.

If you have a low-mid range system i'd suggest sticking with XP SP3, less overheads on XP than on vista.

If you are running a high end system (9800GX2 and above) you wont notice the performence loss if you run vista (you'll be able to SEE it but only getting 200 fps in a game instead of 230 isnt going to cause you any problems).

Most high end systems have 4GB+ of RAM so Vista 64 would be recommended, XP64 has dire driver support.

Another thing to take into consideration is ATi seem to retain performence better on vista than nVidia, Vista has an absolutely awful SLI scaling for games, XP is much better for SLI.

I'm yet to hear of any issues with Crossfire on vista... will update post if i hear something
E8600 @ 4.1ghz / 4GB PC8500 RAM / HIS 4870X2 2048MB / G7 & G15 / 24" Samsung SM2493HM
31
48% Ranking 48% Ranking 48% Ranking 48% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Installed vista x64 recently driver support was fine for me and I haven't noticed any performance decreases as of yet but of course it is not the same for everyone.

4gigsofram
8800gtx
q6600

This comment was edited at 08/20/2008 11:54 AM
:3(|)
32
1% Ranking 1% Ranking 1% Ranking 1% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

16bit for life! XP rocks my world
33
34% Ranking 34% Ranking 34% Ranking 34% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

I have Vista64 and it's amazing, def. faster than when I had XP.
xenoc!de
34
25% Ranking 25% Ranking 25% Ranking 25% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

windows xp is as good as it gets, windows 7 is the new vista, leaving vista in the dust
35
14% Ranking 14% Ranking 14% Ranking 14% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

theres sp2 too nnow for vista
36
43% Ranking 43% Ranking 43% Ranking 43% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

XP is 10 years old, use Vista..., Windows 7 comes out in October and the RC1 is amazing.
e8600@4.3 | evga 790i ftw | gtx260c216 | 4gb DDR3 | 2x 250gig SG raid 0 | 1200w CoolMax |
37
8% Ranking 8% Ranking 8% Ranking 8% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

vista would be better if it wasn't so bloated
38
8% Ranking 8% Ranking 8% Ranking 8% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

JK LOLLLLLL
39
26% Ranking 26% Ranking 26% Ranking 26% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

dual boot slackware and xp
2+2=5

Using XP 64-bit until 7 comes out. No compatibility issues and it's lean and mean.
41
16% Ranking 16% Ranking 16% Ranking 16% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

vista phailed.....i mean hardcore. using xp pro sp3 right now, i have win 7 rc installed on my computer too, i use it some time, its a lot better than vista, plust win 7 offers xp mode, which is super duber cool. will use xp til win7 comes out(later this year)
E8400 @ 3.8GHz | Gigabyte P35-DS3L | 4GB Corsair | Arctic Cooling Freezer Pro 7 | 500GB | 8800gt|

Submit Comments

Registered Users Only

In order to post comments, you must be a registered member. If you have not registered, it's free and easy!

Latest Poll