Tuesday November 24 2009
Story Header

FPSLabs Home: Icemat and Steelsound headsets reviewed

By: Christian Koebel - Published November 17, 2005 at 8:17 PM EST - Writer Archive
We recently had the chance to examine the new Icemat Siberia and Steelsound 5H headset. Find out the results, and how these compare with the current top choice of many gamers, the Sennheiser PC150.

Introduction

With the launch of any new hardware site, it takes a bit of time for companies to start to notice you. It also takes a while to build up a reputation as a good reviewer. Therefore, it's been almost three weeks since the launch of the site and this is our very first review based off of products sent to us. Soft Trading, the parent company behind Steel Series and Icemat, is well known for its support of eSports. This is no exception. Kudos to them for being the first company to send us a product to test, they know a good idea when they see it.

After the launch of this site, I received a sample of the Icemat Siberia as well as the Steelsound 5H from them. Both were the versions of the headsets that featured USB sound cards. Since I personally owned a PC150 from Sennheiser, I figured it would be a good idea to see if these two headsets really do justify their price tag, which is double that of the PC150s. After extensive testing, this is what we here at GotFrag Hardware have decided on in a head-to-head-to-head between the Sennheiser PC150, the Steelsound 5H, and the Icemat Siberia.

Steelsound 5H

First Impressions
The Steelsound 5H came in a very attractive clear plastic package, with the headset mounted on a gray holder with a silver “5H” on it The entire package contains a USB soundcard, a mini-CD containing the drivers and other software for that card, a 3-foot headset extension cable, and the headset itself. Setting it up was incredibly easy with Windows XP, and the audio software to control the USB soundcard was very intuitive.

Design
This headset, from the way it's packaged, to every minor detail of it, was designed for gaming. It is designed to completely cover your ears, but still allows some sound through for a LAN environment.

The microphone boom retracts into the left
side speaker when not needed.
As is the case with most closed-ear headsets, these are extremely comfortable to wear for even hours at a time. In order to adjust to the different sizes of heads, it features the typical sliding speaker system that just about any headset today uses. The microphone stock is designed to be flexible, but also maintain any position you put it in.

The 5Hs modular design
provide for easy transport.
One of the more interesting features of the headset allows the microphone to completely retract into the left speaker. This is actually pretty useful if you want to just use this headset to listen to music on a CD player, or if you just don't want to look like a dork in public. Another neat feature that you LAN jockeys will love is that you can take the headset apart. The padded connecting bar that goes over your head and the two speakers all detach, so you don't have to worry about crushing your headset together when you're getting ready to go to a LAN.

The headset is connected to the rest of the setup via a single cable that carries both the audio output and microphone signals. Then after about 1.5 ft of cord, it reaches the volume control box. This little device lets you have a decent amount of control on the volume of your headset, and also lets you switch your microphone between off mode, low mode, and high mode.

Writing is hard to read.
Unfortunately, the microphone settings are extremely hard to make out, but once you've read them once, it's pretty easy to memorize them. The back of the volume control device has a clip on it for attaching to your shirt, or whatever else might strike your fancy. From here, the signal travels another foot at which point the cable ends. From there, you plug the headset cable into an extension that is another 3 feet long. From here, it can either plug into your sound card in your computer, or into the USB sound card included in this setup. Though it may seem like a lot of cables for a relatively simple device, keep in mind that the makers also wanted you to be able to take these on the road with a CD-player and listen to them. This is why the cable ends at 3 feet with an optional extension. It wouldn't be very convenient to be carrying around 6 feet of cabling wherever you went.

Sound
Design is only half of what makes this headset so obviously built for gamers. The other is the way it sounds. After scrimming a bit of DoD with this headset, I can honestly say it sounds awesome. The bass is deeper and all sounds are crisper than anything I've used before, and I'm used to $50 Sennheiser PC150's! In any game that was played, the sound quality that the 5H's generated were noticeably better than anything I'd ever heard before. Obviously, it is quite hard to describe in words how one headset sounds, but to put it simply, the 5H's provide extremely clear sound, and the bass has a lot of punch. Unfortunately, when it comes to playing music, this headset does not quite pass muster. Though providing superior quality to the PC150's in that respect, it still leaves quite a bit to be desired considering the price tag. However, one must consider that this headset is not designed for listening to music specifically. It is designed for gaming and only gaming, and this is what it excels at to a great degree. The final point I have to make about the sound has to do with positional audio. However, this is covered later, under the review of the USB sound card that actually generates that audio.
Continued (1/4) »
Page:

User Comments

1
35% Ranking 35% Ranking 35% Ranking 35% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

ZeGermans wants some comments, so I felt like I should oblige him.

On a more related note, I'm probably going buy some IceMats soon. I think the Steelsound ones are ugly.
2
62% Ranking 62% Ranking 62% Ranking 62% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

makes me want to get a siberia
#.eP :: extreme Perfection :: cal-main ::
3
98% Ranking 98% Ranking 98% Ranking 98% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

I need to get me one of these :)
4
25% Ranking 25% Ranking 25% Ranking 25% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

The Siberias also look a bit 'stronger' than the 5H, the mic on the 5H looks like it will eventually break constantly taking it out/putting it back in! (audio90 style)

Siberias > 5H :)
5
47% Ranking 47% Ranking 47% Ranking 47% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

GREAT review. Good timing to, I was just looking for reviews on the two.
I LIKE CS TO PLAY
6
33% Ranking 33% Ranking 33% Ranking 33% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Yes this is a MUCH needed review. These 2 headphones are among the top for pc gaming, gj.
7
23% Ranking 23% Ranking 23% Ranking 23% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

I want one :(
8
11% Ranking 11% Ranking 11% Ranking 11% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

i got me some siberias ^-^ theyre hot stuff
[b]^_^[/b]
9
33% Ranking 33% Ranking 33% Ranking 33% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

oops i forgot to say that you might have mixed this up

"The Siberia is a closed-ear headset, and it lets through much less noise than the 5H's"
I have also used both, and I am pretty sure that the 5h cancel outside noise better, and that the Siberia are actually an open-eared headset.
10
13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Very nice article, if I had the money I would probably go for the 5H, seeing as how normal headphones are sufficient for listening to music on the go. I'll await your next article. :)
11
20% Ranking 20% Ranking 20% Ranking 20% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

My SIberia's broke after like 3 weeks. The hing that holds the muff broke cutting the cable that goes the the muff, so no sound. Had to send them back on my dollar. Finally let me know they are shipping me a new pair after 2 weeks.

Great sounding, annoying mic, just be careful with the muffs. Could of been designed much better in that area.
12
35% Ranking 35% Ranking 35% Ranking 35% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

siberias are GREAT dont listen to vinny hes obviously one of those guys who throws their headset around the room :D siberias are really nice ive had mine since summer
Hello I enjoy video games
13
97% Ranking 97% Ranking 97% Ranking 97% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

plantronics audio 110! own
09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0

Mmm... this review makes me happy I just ordered my Siberias. Go go newegg! Somewhat disappointing in that the Plantronic Audio 110 was not reviewed, but whatever. I never really considered it an option.
Gar...
15
33% Ranking 33% Ranking 33% Ranking 33% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

makes me wanna get some siberias, great review.
#1UP
16
30% Ranking 30% Ranking 30% Ranking 30% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Good reviews! Althoguh I believe that the Siberias are open-air. not closed-ear :X.
17
94% Ranking 94% Ranking 94% Ranking 94% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

14, plantronics didn't respond to my emails. I'm still working on getting a pair to review so stay tuned.
18
15% Ranking 15% Ranking 15% Ranking 15% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

siberias are amazing, but they break if you breathe on them too hard
<3 CS
19
18% Ranking 18% Ranking 18% Ranking 18% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

hopefully you will get a pair of audio .110s

This comment was edited at 11/17/2005 11:37 PM
20
23% Ranking 23% Ranking 23% Ranking 23% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

I'd never get rid of my USB PC155 Sennheisers.. The USB of Senn is amazing, much better sounding than the 5H. I can only imagine how the 160SK would sound with the Senn USB sound card.

You should compare the headsets with the PC155USB if not the PC160SK.

The PC150 is ancient history, and it's specs are far below the others that you reviewed, and it headset cost 1/2 of the Icemat and Steel.

This comment was edited at 11/18/2005 12:17 AM
Steelpad S&S SK | Sennheisser PC155 | Intellimouse 1.1
21
19% Ranking 19% Ranking 19% Ranking 19% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

the Steelpad/icemat headphones look horrible and are uncomfortable to wear

I still <3 my Hd570
~white~~~~~~~~diamonds~~~~
22
51% Ranking 51% Ranking 51% Ranking 51% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Nothing is getting better than sennheiser. sorry! HD580's here. A lot of top players use HD 650's. They're just amazing with everything.
Large jungle zone moved to see rapid climate platform when a small defuse kit quick quick -Wikky_Woo
23
51% Ranking 51% Ranking 51% Ranking 51% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

#20 thats absolutely true. If they wanted to set something up more recent with sennheiser, I think both the othe two headsets would be blown away.
Large jungle zone moved to see rapid climate platform when a small defuse kit quick quick -Wikky_Woo
25
117% Ranking 117% Ranking 117% Ranking 117% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

ahhh i dont know what to get next lol
26
38% Ranking 38% Ranking 38% Ranking 38% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

HD580's arn't geared towards gaming... they're also extremely expensive.
So, obviously you'd expect them to be alot better in some respects - they still look crap though.

I've got all three pairs of these headphones and found the 150's to be the worst i've ever used as soon
as I started playing with them, so I got the other 2. I play with Siberias most of the time(without
the soundcard)... Being predominately a CS1.6 player the 5H v7.1 sound didn't help all that much
and the Siberias are so much nicer to wear anyway. Also, the 5H mic had a few problems, as if the
cable twisted inside the mic or something, got mad feedback/static noise when I used it until I wiggled
the mic a bit - probably faulty but have 4 other people who had same problem :( nvm
- d(o_o)b -
27
124% Ranking 124% Ranking 124% Ranking 124% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

I WANT THE PLANTRONICS REVIEW!!!!! But, good job on the reviews. My Audio .90s still rape anything I've ever tried, but that's cool.
28
21% Ranking 21% Ranking 21% Ranking 21% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

maybe a suggestion next time would be for the reviewer to actually give HIS input on which is better and why...just cause for people like me who are indecisive -_-

thanks..great review btw
wo_osa
29
66% Ranking 66% Ranking 66% Ranking 66% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Great review. Maybe a comparison with a newer sennheiser headset would have been fairer. A great very unbiased review though, however, i can see where #28 is coming from where he just wants an opinion. :D
[b]GotFrag Features Writer[/b]
30
89% Ranking 89% Ranking 89% Ranking 89% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

If we ever do a review of a free $20,000 Alienware, I call first dibs

This comment was edited at 11/18/2005 1:32 PM
31
10% Ranking 10% Ranking 10% Ranking 10% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

what is "base"?

BASS.
32
7% Ranking 7% Ranking 7% Ranking 7% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

i haev the sibreas! BOII!
33
94% Ranking 94% Ranking 94% Ranking 94% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

#31:
L!O>L! That was a terrible mistake... updating now.
34
23% Ranking 23% Ranking 23% Ranking 23% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

also, don't get me wrong, but, does 5.1 or even 4.1 sound work in CS? lol

i've tried EAX and A3D .. and they don't do crap on my 5.1 speakers...

with HALF LIFE 1 (and other games) EAX DOES WORK..

in CS u should be able to tell with stereo sound who is where quite easily..
Steelpad S&S SK | Sennheisser PC155 | Intellimouse 1.1
35
23% Ranking 23% Ranking 23% Ranking 23% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

ahl himself told me he'd never leave his sennheisers at home .. he takes them over the 5H...
Steelpad S&S SK | Sennheisser PC155 | Intellimouse 1.1
36
21% Ranking 21% Ranking 21% Ranking 21% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

My Siberias have to be the best headphones I've ever worn, for both music and gaming. This just backs up everytime I've bragged about having them :D
[b]#sharkteam[/b] Cause we eat seals.. [^t]
37
7% Ranking 7% Ranking 7% Ranking 7% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

I love the icemats. But ive already broken two pairs. The screw ports break so the headband falls off. I dont know ne one else who has had this problem. And no i dont have a big head even though both times they broke i was wearing them at my computer. They sent me a new pair so i guess its all good.
38
7% Ranking 7% Ranking 7% Ranking 7% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

#9 no the Siberia's are the closed ear ones, he had it right.

#26 lol i know someone with the same static mic problem with pc150's

This comment was edited at 11/18/2005 4:07 PM
39
14% Ranking 14% Ranking 14% Ranking 14% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

#37, really? They'll send you a new pair? Mine broke as well, the screw port got chipped or something, and the screw flew out along with the flexible band. I ended up finding a way to screw mine back into place, although the screw is very loose, and I have to "rescrew" (if that's a word) every now and then (like three weeks).

I just may take Soft Trading up on that offer to replace my headset if they'll do it...
We have explosive!
40
102% Ranking 102% Ranking 102% Ranking 102% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Icemat's Siberia for the win :] the whiteones look so HAWT
Pittsburgh Steelers 6 Times Superbowl Champions
41
19% Ranking 19% Ranking 19% Ranking 19% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

The 5H's retractable microphone boom is the absolute win.
sweet penance for the sound
42
30% Ranking 30% Ranking 30% Ranking 30% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Hehe, great review.
GotFrag Hardware is awesome.
43
59% Ranking 59% Ranking 59% Ranking 59% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Siberia's sound good, but I gotta have a mic.... = \
44
108% Ranking 108% Ranking 108% Ranking 108% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Amazing review, and if my Sennheiser's break, I will be choosing 1 of these 2 headsets.
I AM LEGEND
45
136% Ranking 136% Ranking 136% Ranking 136% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

I want the Siberia's so bad!
46
18% Ranking 18% Ranking 18% Ranking 18% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

He keeps using the terms "open ear" and "closed ear" incorrectly. All of these headsets are open ear headsets. Just because the earcup covers your entire ear doesn't make that headset closed ear. What they actually refer to is whether the heasphones are designed to keep out noise or allow it in (note, this is different than "noise-cancelling" which is an added feature that furthers the purpose of a closed headset). These headsets are designed to allow you to hear sounds in the room easily.

Here is an example of an over the ear, but still open, headphone.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00005S8..

And here is an example of a closed ear headset that rest on top of your ears, not covering them.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000065B..

Other than that, good article.
Man, sheesh!
47
101% Ranking 101% Ranking 101% Ranking 101% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

I love these reviews :D
48
94% Ranking 94% Ranking 94% Ranking 94% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

#46 good point, I will correct that for my next review.
49
59% Ranking 59% Ranking 59% Ranking 59% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Gonna be using my siberias for a long time to come...
50
11% Ranking 11% Ranking 11% Ranking 11% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Sorry that i have to say that but this review is below average.

1) -How can you expect a guy that uses the term ""closed and open" headsets completely wrong to be able tojudge which headset sounds better.

2)-He takes 3 samples:steelsound (with usb) $140
siberias (with usb) $100
pc150(without usb)$50!!!!!
Not only he/she compares 2 different gategories(165>160>155>150)150 being mid range but also he/she did not review the sennheisers usb sound card.

3)The reviewer did not mention anything about the build quality and support of the products(very important)

4)The reviewer seems to have little expirience/knowledge around the topic since he/she has only been used sennheiser pc150 or below.

5)He/she did not mention the test setup(specifically he did not mention on what sound card he/she was testing pc150 and other headsets). Did he/she used audigy with the pc150?did he used the
steelsound usb???

6)I think the review is biased or sponsored by softtrading since siberias and steesound come from
the same company.

7)lack of intensity test(sound quality at loud volume),lack of microphone quality test,also
did notmention if the usb sound cards work without the drivers(since the phones are made
for lan).

Still have a lot to mention but as you can see there are is not point to continue.

REMEMBER:A bad review is worse than no review.

This comment was edited at 11/24/2005 6:33 PM

More Pages

Submit Comments

Registered Users Only

In order to post comments, you must be a registered member. If you have not registered, it's free and easy!

Latest Poll